Why would Manchester United go after Pochettino?

May 24, 2024

Mauricio Pochettino, one of the most sought-after managers in world football, has been linked with a move to Manchester United. While the Argentine tactician has a proven track record, a potential switch to Old Trafford might not be the best move for either party. Additionally, Chelsea's decision to part ways with Pochettino was ill-judged, considering the circumstances and potential he brought to the club. Here’s a detailed look at why Pochettino to Manchester United is a bad idea and why Chelsea made a mistake in firing him.

Manchester United has struggled with managerial stability since the departure of Sir Alex Ferguson. The club's frequent managerial changes and inconsistent performances highlight a lack of long-term planning. Pochettino, known for his emphasis on building projects and developing young talent, might find it challenging to implement his vision in an environment where short-term results are often prioritized over long-term growth.

The expectations at Manchester United are immense. Fans and the board demand immediate success, both domestically and in Europe. Pochettino, despite his managerial prowess, has yet to win a major trophy in his career. The pressure to deliver silverware at United could overshadow his ability to build and develop a competitive squad over time.

United’s squad requires significant rebuilding, particularly in defence and midfield. While Pochettino has demonstrated an ability to develop players and build cohesive units, the magnitude of the task at United might prove overwhelming. The club needs a manager who can make immediate impactful changes, which might not align with Pochettino’s methodical and patient approach.

The Premier League boasts some of the world’s best managers, including Pep Guardiola, Jurgen Klopp, and Mikel Arteta. Pochettino would face fierce competition in trying to restore United to its former glory. Competing against these tacticians with a squad that requires substantial improvement might set him up for failure, potentially tarnishing his reputation.

Chelsea’s decision to fire Pochettino reflects a lack of patience from the club’s hierarchy. Pochettino, like any manager, needs time to instill his philosophy, develop young talent, and build a cohesive team. Sacking him prematurely denied Chelsea the opportunity to benefit from his long-term vision and project-oriented approach.

Pochettino has a proven track record of developing young players and building competitive squads, as seen during his tenure at Tottenham Hotspur. Chelsea, with a squad brimming with young talent, could have greatly benefited from his expertise in nurturing and maximizing the potential of these players.

Pochettino is known for his tactical flexibility and ability to adapt to different situations. Chelsea’s decision to part ways with him undermined the potential tactical evolution he could have brought to the team. His ability to switch between formations and adapt strategies according to opponents would have added a valuable dimension to Chelsea’s game.

Pochettino had unfinished business at Chelsea, with the potential to lead the club to greater heights. Given more time, he could have addressed the squad’s deficiencies, implemented his tactical vision, and potentially led Chelsea to domestic and European success. Firing him prematurely deprived the club of realizing this potential.

Mauricio Pochettino’s potential move to Manchester United might not be the ideal fit due to the club’s instability, high expectations, and the significant rebuilding required. On the other hand, Chelsea’s decision to fire Pochettino was a mistake, as they failed to recognize the long-term benefits of his managerial style and expertise. Both clubs need to carefully consider their managerial choices to ensure they make decisions that align with their long-term goals and aspirations. For Pochettino, finding a club that values patience, development, and a long-term vision might be the best path forward for his career.