Who's to Blame for the Toronto Blue Jays Early Playoff Exit?

October 6, 2023

The Toronto Blue Jays' recent playoff run ended in disappointment, leaving fans and analysts alike wondering who deserves the most blame for the team's demise. In this post, we'll break down some key moments and decisions while maintaining a neutral perspective on the matter.

One of the pivotal moments that turned the tide against the Blue Jays was Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s base-running blunder. It's hard to overlook the fact that he got thrown out at second base during a critical juncture in the game. Such mental lapses are inexcusable, especially in the high-stakes environment of playoff baseball.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. was expected to be the driving force behind the team's success, yet his performance in the postseason left much to be desired. With only three hits and two walks in six playoff games, the young star fell short of expectations.

Another point of contention revolves around John Schneider, who received criticism for pulling starting pitcher Jose Berrios early in game 2. Many fans and pundits questioned the decision, especially after Berrios had been pitching well, with five strikeouts through 3 innings. Even some postgame comments from players expressed frustration with this choice.

While some argue that this decision may have come from the analytics department or the front office, John Schneider bears the responsibility for managing his pitchers effectively. Berrios had been pitching well and had something to prove against his former team, making his removal from the game a perplexing decision.

In addition to these specific issues, the Blue Jays' inability to deliver in critical moments plagued their playoff campaign. Whether it was Bo Bichette's strikeout in game 2 or running through a stop sign in game 1 and getting thrown out at home, the team's star players failed to rise to the occasion when it mattered most.

Comparing this to the Minnesota Twins' ability to capitalize on key moments and Carlos Correa's standout performance, it becomes evident that clutch plays can make all the difference in postseason baseball.

As the Minnesota Twins advance to face the Houston Astros, the Blue Jays find themselves on the outside looking in. The Twins' success demonstrated that scoring a few timely runs can be enough to win against certain opponents. The Jays had the talent but fell short in executing when it counted the most.